Is it time for a dental checkup?

Root Canal vs. Extraction: Factors Dentists Consider When Choosing a Course of Treatment

Jump To:
Request an Appointment Today

Questions or concerns about a specific dental service or procedure? Contact us now.

Find A Location

Poor oral health can lead to several devastating dental issues, including tooth decay, gum disease, jaw infection, and tooth loss. Your dentist will likely recommend one of two treatments: root canal or extraction for a severely damaged tooth.

Root canal vs. extraction may seem like a straightforward decision; however, there are several factors your dentist will consider when choosing the right course of treatment. Root canal therapy involves removing the infected pulp inside the tooth, replacing it with a special filling material, and sealing it with a crown to protect the tooth from further damage. 

Extraction, on the other hand, is an invasive dental procedure that involves removing the tooth entirely from its socket in the jawbone. The gap is then replaced with a bridge, dentures, or implants. This guide provides a rundown of the elements dentists consider before deciding on a course of treatment. 

Root Canal vs. Extraction: Pros and Cons

Your dentist may recommend either a root canal or an extraction depending on the severity of your tooth decay or injury. The dentist should discuss the pros and cons of either procedure beforehand to ensure you know what to expect.

Root Canal Pros

Root canal therapy is often the preferred course of treatment for its cost-effectiveness, convenience, and ability to save your natural teeth. Its pros include:

  • Preserves the natural tooth and its structure: Root canal therapy, unlike extraction, can maintain the natural tooth structure. No additional procedures or treatments are necessary to replace the missing tooth.
  • Less invasive and virtually painless: You will be under local anesthesia during the procedure, making it virtually painless. The drilling and cleaning process is also less invasive than an extraction.
  • Cost-effective: Although it usually requires 2–3 visits to the dentist, root canal therapy is more cost-effective than extraction and its related procedures, such as dental implant placement. Adopting proper oral hygiene and regular professional cleanings will help extend the life of your root canal therapy.

Root Canal Cons

Root canal therapy does have a few drawbacks, despite being relatively safe and successful. These include:

  • Risk of infection: Poor cleaning, inadequate filling, and unsterilized instruments can increase the risk of re-infection after the procedure. Fractures and cracks in the tooth can also become a breeding ground for bacteria.
  • Weakens the tooth: The drilling process of a root canal can weaken the tooth structure and compromise its integrity, making it more prone to fractures. 

Extraction Pros

Severely decayed or diseased teeth may require extraction to prevent further damage and save the other surrounding teeth. The pros of tooth extraction include the following:

  • Alleviates pain instantly: An extraction can immediately resolve the discomfort, excruciating pain, and sensitivity caused by an infected tooth. You will get back to your regular activities faster with fewer complications.
  • Removes the infection entirely and prevents further damage: Tooth extraction involves removing the entire tooth, including the root. This helps ensure the infection is eliminated and prevents it from spreading to other parts of your mouth.

Extraction Cons

The cons of tooth extraction include the following:

  • Additional costs for replacing the missing tooth: Extraction is a more costly option due to the need for further dental procedures, such as bridges, implants, or dentures. You will need to book multiple visits to the dentist, which can add up quickly.
  • More invasive procedure: Removing a tooth from its socket in the jawbone requires more steps and is much more invasive than a root canal. If performed incorrectly, this may lead to severe complications, such as infection or damage to the surrounding teeth.
  • Risk of infection: The gap left by the missing tooth can become a breeding ground for bacteria that can spread to other parts of your mouth.
  • Impacts your overall appearance: Depending on the location of the missing tooth, you may experience a visible gap in your smile. This can affect your overall appearance and self-esteem. You become more self-conscious and may be reluctant to engage in social situations. 

Dentists consider several factors when deciding between a root canal vs. extraction. This helps ensure you get the proper treatment for your needs, budget, and lifestyle. 

5 Factors Dentists Consider When Choosing Between Root Canal vs. Extraction

Your dentist won’t just hop straight into the procedure. They will first assess your individual needs and determine the best course of action to take based on several factors, including:

1. The Severity of the Infection

How far has the infection spread? Is it localized to just one tooth, or does it impact other teeth and mouth parts? Does the patient have any underlying medical conditions that may affect the outcome? Root canal therapy is viable for mild to moderate infections, while extraction may be recommended for more severe cases. 

2. Location of the Tooth

Root canal therapy is generally recommended for front teeth, incisors, and canines, as they have a single root and are easier to access. Back teeth, such as molars, have a complex anatomy with multiple roots, making it harder to clean and fill the canals. Extraction may be easier and more cost-effective in this case. 

3. Patient’s Age and Health Status

Older patients and those with certain health conditions like diabetes, heart disease, or hypertension may opt for tooth extraction due to the risk of complications. It’s a faster, less invasive procedure with shorter recovery times. 

Younger patients and those in good health may be suitable for root canal therapy, as they can have better outcomes and long-term success. 

4. Cost of Treatment

A considerable factor in choosing a root canal vs. extraction is, of course, what the patient can afford and is willing to pay for. Root canal therapy is more expensive but offers a higher success rate with lasting results. 

Tooth extraction is quicker and cheaper, but you may need to consider additional restorative procedures to replace the missing tooth. Gaps in teeth can cause misalignment and speech issues, so your dentist may recommend a bridge, implant, or denture to restore your smile’s natural look and function.

5. Patient’s Comfort Level and Pain Tolerance

The dentist aims to ensure that every patient feels safe, comfortable, and relaxed throughout the procedure. Some patients may be more anxious and prefer the quicker, less invasive option of extraction. Others may be willing to endure a few hours of discomfort in exchange for long-term results with a root canal. 

Your dentist will discuss beforehand what to expect in each case and help you decide which option is best for you. 

The decision between root canal vs. extraction should always be made in consultation with a qualified dentist. It depends largely on your individual needs, health status, and budget. Your dentist will assess the severity of the infection, the location of the tooth, the cost of treatment, and your preferences to devise a plan that works best for you. 

Maintain Optimal Oral Health with the Professionals

Don’t let fear or anxiety keep you from getting the treatment you need to achieve and maintain optimal oral health. Qualified and experienced dental specialists at The Dental Team are committed to providing the highest quality of care tailored to your needs and preferences. Schedule a consultation at any of our convenient locations and get the proper treatment you deserve.

More Blog Posts

Request an Appointment Today

Questions or concerns about a specific dental service or procedure? Contact us now.

IT Support by SADOSSecure, Fast Hosting for WordPress

Upcoming Holiday Hours

Our offices will be closed on April 7-8, 2023 in observance of the Easter holiday.